The Pink Collar Tightening

By Dr Zara Nanu MBE

It took women fifty years to walk into the office economy. AI could walk them right back out and into the care work the UK has never paid fairly for.

There is a strange symmetry forming in the British labour market. The roles disappearing fastest from corporate plans (administration, customer service, paralegal work, junior clerical) are overwhelmingly held by women.

The roles that are short of workers (nursing, social care and early years) are also overwhelmingly held by women.

Anyone looking at the economic and employment data with a wider policy lens will say that if women are displaced from their work, there are plenty of jobs available in shortage sectors.

But then we have to be realistic about what this means for the shape of the next decade for working women in Britain: out of the mid-pay office jobs that closed the gender pay gap and into the low-pay care jobs the country has, over the same half-century, declined to value.

Transformation rarely protects headcount

The International Labour Organisation’s global index of generative AI occupational exposure finds that women in high-income countries are nearly three times more likely than men to be working in the jobs most exposed to automation: 9.6 per cent of female employment, compared with 3.5 per cent for men. The ILO is clear that transformation of jobs, rather than wholesale replacement, is the most likely outcome.

But transformation rarely protects headcount in roles already seen as routine. Applied to the UK’s female workforce of around 16.7 million, that suggests roughly 1.6 million British women are working in the most exposed occupations.

These are the women who worked hard to narrow the gender pay gap. Over the past fifty years, the gap has narrowed by roughly two-thirds. It did not narrow because the country decided to be fairer, or because Equal Pay legislation delivered results. It narrowed because women advanced into white-collar service work in numbers that bent the average. These jobs are now under threat.

On the other side of the same labour market dominated by women is the work the machine cannot do: looking after children, washing the elderly, feeding the disabled, sitting with the dying, holding together the complicated relational lives of people who can no longer hold their own together.

In England alone, around 1.6 million people work in adult social care. The broader health and social work sector employs 3.77 million women. Eighty-nine per cent of registered nurses are women. These are, by a wide margin, the largest female-dominated occupations in the country, and they are growing.

Skills for Care, the workforce body for adult social care in England, projects that the sector will need an additional 410,000 posts by 2040 to keep pace with population ageing. More than a quarter of the current workforce is already 55 or older.

Vacancies have fallen to a ten-year low of 6.2 per cent, but that is still around three times the rate of the wider economy, in a sector whose demand is only going one way.

The bare minimum

According to recent data, twenty-six per cent of care workers are now paid the legal minimum. The country that says it needs hundreds of thousands more care workers is only prepared to pay them the bare minimum.

Since the start of 2025, the UK government has announced a £2 billion AI Action Plan, a £500 million Sovereign AI Unit, £1.6 billion of UKRI funding directed at AI over four years, £28.2 billion across five new AI Growth Zones, and a £2 billion partnership with Nvidia.

The press releases and the accompanying documents run to hundreds of pages. The word ‘productivity’ appears constantly, and the word ‘women’, where it appears at all, appears in passing reference to STEM pipelines. No gender impact assessment of the labour market transition has been published alongside any of it.

No retraining programme has been announced specifically targeting the female-dominated occupations that statistical modelling consistently identifies as the most exposed. And there has been almost no serious discussion of what this transition means for pay.

The British gender pay gap was not narrowed by accident, and it will not continue to narrow by accident. It narrowed as women entered the office economy and better paid work. Cut the office economy, and the gap reopens, unless we decide otherwise and create opportunities that pay a proper wage, have clear progression pathways, and offer flexibility and job security.

We can’t afford fifty years of progress being walked back, in pink collars, on minimum wage.

Dr Zara Nanu MBE is a pay equity expert and entrepreneur who has spent a decade arguing that fair pay is not an HR problem, but an economic one. She is the CEO and Co-Founder of WorkVue, the founder of Gapsquare (acquired by RELX), a Professor in Practice at the University of Bristol Business School, and the Co-Chair of the West of England Women’s Commission. She sits on the Harvard Kennedy School Women’s Leadership Board and the Equal Pay International Coalition. Her book, The Payslip: Why We’ve Got Pay Wrong and How to Fix It Before AI Makes It Worse, is forthcoming in May 2027.

Next
Next

Women in leadership webinar: making talent visible